Getting started with our buylist

1. Find the card you want to sell using the search box above, or by browsing by set.
2. Once you̱ve found the card, just click the “Sell” button to add it to your buylist cart.
3. When you̱re done adding cards, click the cart link at the top of the page. You can also edit quantities or remove cards from your cart on this page.
4. Follow the checkout prompts to complete your buylist order.
5. Wait for an email confirming that your buylist was accepted. This usually takes less than a day.
6. Check the confirmation email for any changes to your buylist, and make sure your cards are sorted in the same order they are listed in the confirmation email.
7. Mail your cards to Eudemonia!

Buylist details and policies

Please read the following information carefully before submitting your buylist order!

Payment

We offer payment by PayPal, Check, or Store Credit. Please note that PayPal may deduct a small fee if you choose to recieve payment via PayPal; refer to PayPaḻs fee schedule for more information.

We offer 30% more in Store Credit on all non-Bulk items. Store Credit can be used toward the purchase of anything we sell, including Magic singles, sealed product, and gaming accessories. Store Credit never expires, so if you areṉt ready to spend it, you can hold onto it for as long as you like.

Card criteria

We only buy English cards. If we receive foreign cards in place of English cards, we reserve the right to discount their price by up to 50%, or return them to your at your expense.

Please double-check the condition of your cards. The prices listed on our buylist are for cards in Near Mint condition. If we recieve cards in less thatn Near Mint condition, we reserve the right to discount their price up to 75%, or return them to you at your expense. See our card condition guide for details.

Please sort your cards to match the order in which they appear in the confirmation email. If your cards arrive out of order, there may be delays in processing your buylist. In extreme cases, such as large buylists arriving in random order, we may assess a penalty of up to 10% of the final value, or return the entire order.

Due to the constant fluctuation of card values, we ask that all buylist orders be received at our store within 10 days of their acceptance. After that time, all prices are subject to change.

If we intend to discount the value of your buylist, or return it, we will contact you first.

We buy collections!

Got a large collection you’d like to sell? Bring it into the store, and we’ll assess it for you! Depending on the size of the collection, we may ask you to leave it with us for up to a week while we assess it; we’ll give you a receipt, and make you an offer when we’re done. If you’re not satisfied with the offer, you can simply take your cards back.

If you’d like a rough estimate before dropping off your cards, feel free to contact us at info@eudogames.com with a detailed description of your collection, including the names and editions of any valuable cards, and their condition. Remember, though, that we can’t make you an actual offer until we’ve actually seen your cards.

We buy bulk!

Looking to get rid of your junk commons? We’ll buy them! Our bulk rates are as follows:

• Rares & Mythic Rares: 5¢ each
• Uncommons: 1¢ each
• Commons: ¹/₁₀¢ each, or 1¢ per 10 cards

Bulk cards are not eligible for the Store Credit bonus. We generally only accept bulk cards in Near Mint condition and in English. At this time, we are only able to offer Store Credit (not check or PayPal) for bulk cards unless they are part of a large collection.

Mailing guidelines

Please include a printed copy of your confirmation email with your cards, to make sure we can locate your order in our system and pay you in a timely fashion!

Please sort your cards to match the order in which they appear in the confirmation email. If your cards arrive out of order, there may be delays in processing your buylist. In extreme cases, such as large buylists arriving in random order, we may assess a penalty of up to 10% of the final value, or return the entire order.

Take care to package your cards securely to avoid damage during shipment. Do not use plastic bags or rubber bands! We recommend using plastic card cases, or other boxes designed specifically for trading cards. We prefer that you do not sleeve your cards, as we must unsleeve every card in order to grade it.

Address all packages to:

We strongly recommend that you purchase tracking and insurance for your package. Occasionally things do get lost or damaged in the mail, and we cannot be responsible for postal errors. Tracking and insurance are cheap and easy ways to protect your package!

We will send you an email when we receive your package, and another once we have graded your cards and determined their final value, usually within two (2) business days of receipt.

Remember, any cards that are not in Near Mint condition or are not in English will have their value discounted. If you are uncomfortable receiving a reduced price for such cards, please inspect them closely before sending them to make sure they meet our criteria, and include a physical note with your cards indicating that you would prefer to have such cards returned to you at your expense. If we intend to discount the total value of your buylist by more than 15%, we will contact you first.